The Contest for Athens in Brief
In Athenian myth, Athena and Poseidon both wanted to become the patron god of Athens and the land of Attica. Each offered the city a gift. Poseidon struck the rock of the Acropolis with his trident and produced a spring of salt water. Athena planted the first olive tree. The judges awarded the city to Athena, and Poseidon, furious, flooded the land.
That’s the core of the story, but ancient writers told it in several different ways: who judged, what Poseidon offered and how the decision was made all vary. The myth also had physical evidence. For centuries, Athenians pointed visitors to the very spots on the Acropolis where the contest was supposed to have taken place.
Poseidon’s Gift: A Salt Spring (or a Horse?)
In the earliest accounts, Poseidon’s gift is sea water. Herodotus, writing in the 5th century BCE, mentions a “sea” on the Acropolis, a salt-water spring, that the Athenians said Poseidon had created during the contest. The mythographer Apollodorus says Poseidon struck the middle of the Acropolis with his trident and brought up a sea, which in Apollodorus’s day was called the Erechtheis. In Ovid’s Metamorphoses, Athena (as Minerva) weaves the scene into a tapestry, showing Poseidon striking the rock and sea water leaping out.
Many modern retellings give Poseidon a horse instead, a gift of speed and strength in war. The horse fits Poseidon well, since he was the god of horses, and the idea appears in some later sources. But the older tradition, and the one tied to the physical sites in Athens, is the salt spring.
Either way, the gift was meant to sound impressive and turn out less useful. A spring of salt water on a hilltop is a wonder, but no one can drink it.
Athena’s Gift: The Olive Tree
Athena planted an olive tree on the Acropolis. The olive gave food, oil for cooking and lamps, oil for washing and athletics, and wood. It became central to Athenian life and wealth.
Athenians kept a sacred olive tree on the Acropolis that they believed was Athena’s original. Herodotus tells a striking story about it: when the Persians captured Athens in 480 BCE, they burned the Acropolis and the tree with it. The very next day, Athenians who went up to sacrifice found that a new shoot about a cubit long had already sprung from the burned stump, a sign that the goddess had not abandoned the city.
Olive oil from Athena’s sacred trees was later given as the prize at the Panathenaic Games, held in special painted jars, the Panathenaic amphorae, which showed Athena in her armor.
Who Judged the Contest?
The sources disagree about who decided the winner.
- The twelve gods. Apollodorus says Zeus separated the quarreling gods and appointed judges, and that the judges were the twelve gods, not, as some said, local kings. He notes the alternative versions himself, which tells us several were in circulation.
- Cecrops as witness. In Apollodorus’s account, Athena called Cecrops, the legendary first king of Athens, who was half man and half serpent, to witness her planting the olive. Poseidon had acted first, but the judges awarded the land to Athena because Cecrops testified that she had planted the olive before Poseidon produced the sea.
- Local kings. Other versions, mentioned by Apollodorus, made Cecrops or the early kings Cranaus or Erysichthon the judges.
- The people of Athens. A Roman version, below, puts the decision to a vote of the citizens.
Ovid’s tapestry shows the twelve gods seated in judgment with Zeus in the middle, so the “divine jury” version was well known by Roman times.
Poseidon’s Revenge
Poseidon didn’t take defeat well. Apollodorus says that in his anger he flooded the Thriasian plain, west of Athens, and put Attica under the sea. Losing a contest and then punishing the winners with water is something of a habit for Poseidon, as the last section shows.
The Women’s Vote: Varro’s Version
The most unusual version comes from the Roman scholar Varro, preserved by Saint Augustine in The City of God. In this telling, an olive tree and a spring of water appeared suddenly on the Acropolis. King Cecrops asked the oracle of Apollo at Delphi what they meant, and was told that the people must choose which of the two gods to name the city after.
All the citizens, men and women alike, voted. The men voted for Poseidon (Neptune) and the women for Athena (Minerva). There was one more woman than man, so Athena won. Poseidon flooded the land in anger, and to appease him, the Athenians punished the women: from then on, women would have no vote, children would not take their mothers’ names, and women would not be called “Athenians.”
Augustine was using the story to criticize pagan religion, and it’s impossible to know how old the tradition behind it is. It’s notable as a myth that explains, and in a sense justifies, the exclusion of women from Athenian political life.
The Evidence on the Acropolis
Athenians didn’t treat the contest as a distant legend. They showed it off.
- The Erechtheion, the temple on the north side of the Acropolis, contained the salt-water “sea” of Poseidon. The travel writer Pausanias says that when the south wind blew, the well made a sound like waves, and that the rock bore the mark of a trident.
- The sacred olive grew nearby, in the precinct of Pandrosos, one of Cecrops’s daughters. Pausanias also records the story of its miraculous regrowth after the Persian fire.
- The Parthenon’s west pediment, the sculpted triangle above the main entrance side visitors first approached, showed the contest itself, according to Pausanias. The east pediment showed Athena’s birth from the head of Zeus. Only fragments of the west pediment survive, but drawings made in the 17th century, before the Parthenon was badly damaged in 1687, record much of the composition.
Poseidon wasn’t excluded from the Acropolis after his defeat. He shared the Erechtheion, where he was worshipped together with the hero Erechtheus, and Athenians honored him elsewhere in Attica, most famously at the temple of Poseidon at Cape Sounion.
What the Myth Meant to Athenians
The contest is a myth about identity. It answered the question of why Athens belonged to Athena, and it put Athena’s values at the heart of the city: craft, intelligence and the steady prosperity of the olive, rather than the raw power of the sea.
It’s also a little ironic. In the 5th century BCE, Athens became the greatest naval power in Greece, its wealth and empire built on the sea that Poseidon had offered. Some modern readers see the myth as an echo of that tension: a city devoted to Athena, but dependent on Poseidon’s domain.
There’s an old question of whether Athens was named after Athena or the goddess after the city. The city’s Greek name, Athenai, is plural, and many scholars think the two names share an origin in a word older than Greek itself, so the myth’s answer may reverse the historical one.
For more on Athena’s owl, aegis and olive, see our guide to the symbols of the Greek gods.
Poseidon the Sore Loser: His Other Contests
Athens wasn’t Poseidon’s only lost contest. The ancient writer Plutarch remarked on how often he was beaten, listing Athens, Delphi, Argos, Aegina and Naxos among the places he lost or gave up. A few of the best-known disputes:
- Argos: Poseidon and Hera competed for the city. According to Pausanias, the local river gods judged in Hera’s favor, and Poseidon took revenge by making their waters disappear, which explained why Argive rivers ran dry outside of rain.
- Corinth: Poseidon disputed the land with Helios, the sun. The Hundred-Hander Briareus arbitrated, giving Poseidon the Isthmus and Helios the high citadel of Acrocorinth.
- Troezen: Here Zeus ordered Athena and Poseidon to share the city, and Pausanias says the people honored both.
These contests reflect real cult history: cities with powerful local gods explaining why Poseidon held second place. They also fit his character. Poseidon is one of the mightiest gods, as our article on the strongest gods in Greek mythology explains, but he keeps losing to rivals who are cleverer or better connected. For more on both rivals and their place among the gods, see who the 12 Olympian gods are or our A-Z guide to the Greek gods.